Going on duty


 
At left, Josie Bowman gives her son, Lucas Al, 4, his final hug before she departs for active duty from the New Mexico National Guard Armory in Gallup, N.M., Monday, February 10, 2003. Bowman, along with others, volunteered to go on active duty.

Photo by Douglas Tesner



Cibola hospital crisis spurs recall threat


Jim Tiffin
Staff Writer

GRANTS — The medical community and residents warned the county commission they will actively oppose its Jan. 30 lawsuit filed against Cibola General Hospital, including possible recall of commissioners.

The county placed a legal notice in the Albuquerque Journal Sunday inviting bids for purchase of the hospital, prompting a standing room only crowd of about 75 people for the board meeting Monday.

Eighteen area physicians, pharmacists, optometrists and other health care providers in the Grants area presented a signed letter to the board accusing the commissioners of a "violation of the trust given to them by the voters of this county."

Dr. David Pitts, an internal medicine specialist, presented the letter.

After the meeting Pitts said: "We've been here for 10 years and there have been tremendous changes in our medical facility, we stuck it out.

"If it (the hospital) is altered in its administration or management, or closes, we will see people suffer and die.

"And this all because the county commissioners see an ability to take health care dollars and put them toward a county jail."

The letter presented by Pitts stated during two meetings, Dec. 16 and 23, 2002 both Ulibarri and county employee Bob Ewell told members of the hospital board of trustees that the funds from the hospital will be used to pay interest on the loan payments for the new jail, which was recently awarded Jaynes Corp. of Albuquerque for nearly $6 million.

The letter also stated: "The tragedy of this situation is that the County Commissioners are spending our tax dollars to sue our County Hospital Corporation. This in turn requires the hospital corporation to use funds that were earmarked for improvements and equipment necessary to benefit the health care of the county residents," to counter the lawsuit.

"The diversion of these funds, and federal funds, to any purpose other than health care for the county residents will jeopardize the continued operation of our hospital and indeed may be illegal."

During an emotional presentation during the meeting, Ray Jenkins, of Grants, said the only reason the commission was going after hospital funds is to "cover up the ineptitude of the board."

He said if the commission continues with its lawsuit a recall effort will be launched. People in the room and hallway erupted into applause at the comment.

Recall as a solution to ending the lawsuit was echoed after the meeting by several people as they were standing in the hall discussing the situation.

In the hallway, Dr. Monique Gibson said if the county became successful in taking over the hospital or selling it she intended to end her admitting privileges there.

"I cannot speak for all of the physicians here, but I am sure several of them will also cancel admitting privileges, and with no patients being admitted, they will not have much of a hospital," she said.

Gibson also said the county will lose the federal sole provider funds from the federal government if it sells the hospital.

"And that's the funds they are after," she said.

Hospital CEO Vince Ashley said he wasn't expecting to see the notice in the Albuquerque Journal Sunday that the county was seeking bids to sell the hospital.

The legal notice was placed only in the Journal and gives bidders until Feb. 20 to submit bids to purchase the hospital.

"We are only looking at all of our options," County Manager David Ulibarri said.

'We are only trying to get enough information to provide options to the county commissioners to make a viable decision about the hospital. It says right in the notice that the county can reject any or all bids," he said.

MaryLee Meisner, of Grants, a teacher at Los Alamitos Middle School, told the board it is putting health care in the county in jeopardy.

"How can you sit there and tell me that you are suing me with my tax dollars, for my tax dollars?" she asked.

After those who wanted to address the board about the hospital finished their comments, Commissioner Bennie Cohoe told the audience the commissioners have certain responsibilities to constituents whether those in the room agreed with that or not.

In response to the letter and the threat of a recall effort Board Chairman Isaac Padilla said: "I welcome anyone from the county to run for public office, and sit in this chair and make these decisions.

"Every once in awhile everyone gets riled up over an issue then it dies down."

The hospital filed a counterclaim Feb. 3 to the nearly $4 million lawsuit filed by the county

The county's suit alleges the hospital board of trustees had not paid "net profits" to the county for the past seven years in breach of a management agreement between the two entities.

The counterclaim denies all allegations and asks the court for a temporary injunction to be followed by a permanent injunction prohibiting the county from interfering with or being able to gain funds from the hospital.

The claim also asks the court to prohibit the termination of the hospital board and that the court rule in favor of the hospital stating it is not in default of a management agreement.

Board Chairwoman Patti McClure, said previously, "We are sympathetic to the county's financial position but we can't fix it for them."

She also has been reported saying that if the county wins the suit the hospital closes.

|
Top |


Get MADD about DWIs, planners say

Larry Di Giovanni
Staff Writer

CROWNPOINT — The Navajo Nation can use a proactive approach to combat the continual onslaught of tragedies and their victims created by DUI-related accidents and fatalities, says reservation resident Diane Porter.

Starting with a weekful of kickoff events slated to begin Monday, Feb. 24 in the Crownpoint High School gymnasium, Porter and a group of about eight other adults — mostly mothers — plan to become part of the solution. They are forming a local Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD) Chapter and are encouraging all area adults and students to join their cause.

"We're hoping that this will be the first (MADD Chapter) on the Navajo Nation and that other towns on the reservation will follow suit," Porter said.

The kickoff week to pursue national recognition of a local MADD Chapter will start Feb. 24 at 10 a.m. with a "Navajo Nation-MADD Proclamation Week"ceremony in the Crownpoint High gym. Navajo President Joe Shirley Jr., who met in mid January with group organizers, is scheduled to take part. The proclamation ceremony will be followed by a fund-raiser luncheon that Porter hopes will be attended by at least 200 people. The luncheon will be prepared courtesy of culinary arts students who attend the Crownpoint Institute of Technology.

Porter said it is somewhat remarkable that a MADD Chapter hasn't been proposed on the Navajo Nation until now, given what a serious problem alcoholism and DUIs are here and in border towns such as Gallup. Crownpoint alone has the unfortunate recent history of being the site of a harrowing Halloween crash that left children the victims after the car they were traveling in to go trick-or-treating was hit while entering — of all places — the Crownpoint Indian Health Service Hospital. Crownpoint is also the home of the infamous Lloyd Larson — the BIA employee who in a drunken driving spree while driving on the wrong side of Interstate 40, plowed into the vehicle of and took the lives of two Nebraska couples.

"We've learned that there's not even a MADD Chapter in Gallup," said Porter, who's a temporary employee under contract at the Crownpoint IHS hospital. "That really surprised me. It's more of a close-knit city."

Mothers Against Drunk Driving focuses on three goals: reducing the incidences of drunk driving in communities through greater awareness and preventive public education and outreach; assisting the victims of drunk driving; and reducing underage drinking. Of the handful of women and men from the Crownpoint area who are forming a local MADD Chapter, Alberta Becenti is one to give much of the credit to, Porter said. She cited Becenti, the Crownpoint hospital's director of Health Promotions, as having "the initial vision" for the effort.

Porter is a former Crownpoint Institute of Technology dean, and was acting in that capacity during Halloween evening when tragedy occurred. She recalled how the students involved in causing the crash were some of her own students, and how — because of little jail space — they were released within four hours. One of the major problems confronting all Navajo communities is what form of punishment is appropriate for DUI offenders who cause tragedies, since a long-term jail sentence is not a real option due to limited space.

At Crownpoint High School, students have a Teen Court that's showing some success with alternative sentencing. In her own experience, Porter said she has learned that mandatory counseling doesn't work unless the person to be counseled "really wants the help." As a worker at the Crownpoint IHS hospital, Porter has heard harrowing tales of inebriated parents who send their children — youths without a driver's license — into town to buy their booze. In one recent case, Porter said the child driving without a driver's license was urged to make a liquor run by his mother, who was in the back seat. At CIT, Porter knew students "who were full-blown alcoholics and some on their way."

The point is, alcoholism is a disease, and DUI tragedies are its most unfortunate aftermath, a fact of reservation life, Porter said. A MADD Chapter can start to make a dent in the problem if enough people will join up. In order to move from a Level 1 organizing group to Level 2 — a nationall recognized MADD Chapter — will require getting at least 19 people to sign on, Porter said. The membership fee is $20 per person. MADD provides funds for nationally recognized chapters, which can be used to sponsor events.

For those interested in joining the Crownpoint MADD Chapter, Porter can be reached at home, (505) 786-7231.

Other MADD Chapter kickoff activities scheduled the week of Feb. 24-28 will be:

Tuesday, Feb. 25: Public debate on DUI issues, 3:30 to 5 p.m. in CIT multipurpose room, involving Crownpoint High School and CIT students

Wednesday, Feb. 26: Informational sessions, 8:30 a.m. to noon, Fetal Alcohol Syndrome and impacts of DUI

Thursday, Feb. 27: Candlelight vigil, 6 p.m., Crownpoint Police Department to Crownpoint Elementary School

| Top |


Navajos oppose appointment of Ross Swimmer

Jim Maniaci
Diné Bureau

WINDOW ROCK — The Navajo Nation continues to oppose the appointment of Ross Swimmer as the Special Trustee for American Indians in the U.S. Interior Department because the country's largest tribe considers him a traitor to Diné interests when the controversial Peabody coal royalty rates were determined almost two decades ago.

In a press release Monday, Council Speaker Lawrence Morgan and President Joe Shirley reminded that they sent letters last week to 17 of the 100 Senators — the six senators from the three states that include the Navajo Reservation and members of the committee that will consider the nomination.

In a press release Monday, the tribe restated its "strong opposition to the appointment," according to Carolyn Calvin, Legislative Branch press officer.

On Jan. 3, U.S. President George W. Bush announced he intended to nominate Swimmer, of Oklahoma, and the U.S. Senate Indian Affairs Committee is scheduled to consider it Wednesday.

Calvin said that in addition to Senators Pete Domenici and Jeff Bingaman of New Mexico, John McCain and Jon Kyl of Arizona, Orrin Hatch and Robert Bennett of Utah, the following senators received the Navajo letters citing the 20th Navajo Nation Council's resolution adopted in late January: Daniel Inouye, Lisa Murkowski, Ben Nighthorse Campbell, James Inhofe, Craig Thomas, Maria Cantwell, Tim Johnson, Byron Dorgan, Daniel Akaka, Harry Reid, Kent Conrad and Gordon Smith.

The Navajo leaders wrote they oppose Swimmer because of his "past conduct which resulted in a breach of fiduciary duty to he Navajo Nation in connection with the Peabody coal lease at Black Mesa while he was the Assistant Secretary of Indian
Affairs at the United States Department of the Interior."

This is the position the tribe has maintained in a pair of $600 million lawsuits against the Interior Department for when Donald Hodell was secretary and against the St. Louis, Mo.-based, international coal company. The U.S. Supreme Court is expected to rule by the end of June on the suit against the government in the case that will have a tremendous impact on tribal-federal relations and possibly the U.S. Treasury.

The letter continued, "Mr. Swimmer's favoritism for Peabody has had tremendous effect on the Navajo people as a whole, resulting in the loss of millions of dollars. As a result, Navajo people were robbed of revenue that could have been used for services such as educational scholarships and public safety."

In 1984, the tribe exercised its right to try to raise the initial royalty rate for each ton of coal mined. The BIA Navajo Area (now Region) Office in Gallup recommended 20 percent. But the tribe claims Peabody got a friend of Hodell's to convince him to set it at 12.5 percent, the standard U.S. minimum. It had been less than 3 percent.

The letter called what happened interference and improper influence "to the detriment of the Navajo Nation... (which) was force to agree to a much lower royalty rate than had been determined (to be) appropriate by the Secretary of the Interior's designee, the Navajo Area Director.. (and) was forced to waive back taxes, back royalties and future taxes. Due to Peabody's influence, the United States Government was less than honest and candid in (its) dealings with the Navajo government, Navajo officials and (the) Navajo people."

Morgan concluded Swimmer's record shows he would not act in his trust beneficiaries best interest.

The press release said Sen. Campbell of Colorado already has expressed his support for the Navajo position.

President Shirley, in Salt Lake City on Monday for the annual Utah Legislature's Indian Day, was not available for additional comment.

Nor was Peabody available, as the statement was sent out after 5 p.m.

| Top |


Speaker Morgan: Chapter independence is possible

Jim Maniaci
Diné Bureau

WINDOW ROCK — The new Navajo Nation Council Speaker believes if everyone bends just a little, the compromises will lead to many more chapters being able to run their own operations independent of the central government.

That has been a goal since former president Albert Hale's local empowerment campaign became the Local Governance Act, perhaps the 18th Council's most monumental piece of legislation.

When adopted in April 1998, the expectation was that within four years all 110 chapters would be on their own. But progress has been slower than a turtle in a winter storm. Only two small rural chapters — and none of the urban ones with the most to gain financially for their urban communities — have received their certificates from a council Transportation-Community Development Committee.

New Speaker Lawrence Morgan should know as he was the 19th Council's "T-CDC" chairman when Shonto of the Western Agency and Nahat'a Dziil (New Lands) of the Fort Defiance Agency achieved the hard to get approval of their five-part management system from then Auditor General Elsie Benally. The Auditor General must make a recommendation to the panel before it can consider granting an "LGA" certificate to a chapter.

Morgan said in an interview Monday, "The chapters need to regroup and have someone from a higher office assist them in getting their papers together to submit" for approval.

He believes the Auditor General's checklist should be made public and promoted so the chapters pushing for their certification know what to expect.

Morgan also pointed to his platform to be elected speaker in which he commits to having an accountant"for all the chapters."

Promising"to rebuild the trust with the chapters" he said,"This entails some compromises by the T-CDC, some compromises by the Auditor General and some compromises by the chapters."

The last week of the month is being targeted for a two or three-day special session about the Water Rights Commission and the Statutory Reform Convention proposed changes, mostly at the central government.

Morgan believes the biggest single problem facing the council is, without a doubt, "the water issue."

He said that after water rights, "the secondary issue is the drought that is facing us. If we wait until the spring to get ready, it will be too late. We need to address this soon for the chapters." Morgan represents the Iyanbito and Pinedale Chapters east of Gallup.

The new speaker said that by the end of next week, he should have all his permanent staff appointments made. Already he has retained Leonard Gorman as chief of staff and Randall Morgan as legislative liaison, but added that Morgan's duties will be expanded.

He added he is as anxious to make the appointments as the delegates are because they said during the winter session that they are eager to work with the staff.

As the chief executive of the Legislative Branch, the speaker approves — or rejects — committee requests to meet off the reservation.

Morgan said he will "scrutinize" such requests because "we need to save as much as we can now because of those continuing resolutions." The resolutions by Congress authorize a partial payment for a limited time of federal funds for the current fiscal year based on a percentage of last year's budget.

This causes repeated crises for the tribal departments which obtain their money from Washington, D.C. During the winter session two weeks ago, the council had to bail out the scholarship office and more than 1,000 Navajo college students.

Delegates approved dipping into the Undesignated Reserve Fund, an emergency account that is supposed to contain about $55 million. With the withdrawal — to be paid back when Congress finally approves the budget half-way through the fiscal year — the account is down to only $5 million.

The new speaker fears similar crises might bankrupt the fund.

Morgan, now 49, has been on the council continuously for 12 years as part of a political career spanning almost two decades.
The father of five, whose oldest daughter is in the military reserves and waiting deployment, was Pinedale Chapter manager from 1981-83, chapter secretary-treasurer from 1983-87, chapter president from 1987-91 when he was elected to the council.
He served on the Government Services Committee before shifting over to the "T-CDC." In 1975 he began two years of work as a case eligibility worker for the tribal Social Services Division, then was a community development specialist for the Southwest Indian Foundation in Gallup.

Morgan also serves on the Wingate High School, Wingate Elementary School, and Mariano Lake School boards of directors.
He has a son at the high school and a daughter at the middle schools at Fort Wingate. His other two daughters are married.

The speaker is a 1972 Wingate High school graduate who also attended Diné College and University of New Mexico-Gallup.

In his spare time he enjoys horses and eagerly participates in the council's annual historic trail ride in which delegates and friends spend about a week on a different trail each year, arriving at the Navajo Nation Fairgrounds the day before the summer session begins on the third Monday of July.

| Top |


Area Sports

Kirtland 87, Shiprock 46


KIRTLAND — Kirtland routed Shiprock 87-47 Friday in District 1-4A play.

Kirtland (13-4, 3-1) led 25-11, 45-18, 71-38 before winning by 40 points, 87-47.

Kirtland was paced by Devon Manning with 29 points, Dax Crum 22 and Matthew Benally 16.

Shiprock's leading scorer was Jeffrey Tome with 21 points.

Monument Valley 67, Window Rock 58

FORT DEFIANCE, Ariz. — Monument Valley outscored Window Rock 17-10 to pull out a 67-58 conference win Saturday.

"We spread the court in the fourth quarter," Monument Valley coach Richard Beverly said. "We were up by 20 points and we let them get back in. My boys didn't finish the game."

Monument Valley had Clayton Edd with 19 points, Ian Delmar 13 and Kyle Philips 11.

Window Rock's Farentino Tsosie led all scorers with a game-high 32 points in a losing effort.

In the first round of regionals, Hopi will play at Winslow and Window Rock will be at Tuba City Tuesday. All games are at 7:30 p.m. for the first two rounds. The winner of the Hopi-Winslow game will play at Holbrook and the winner of the Window Rock-Tuba City will be at Ganado Wednesday.

In the Final Four, the winner of the Hopi-Winslow versus Holbrook game will play No. 2 Monument Valley at 1:30 p.m.
Friday. The winner of the Window Rock-Tuba City versus Ganado game will play No. 1 seed Greyhills at 7:30 p.m. The third
place game is set for 11:30 a.m. with the boys finals at 7 p.m. Saturday. The final four will played at Monument Valley.

Ramah 82, Alamo-Navajo 72

RAMAH — Ramah swept a pair of district games over the weekend, downing Quemado 66-58 Friday and then beating Alamo-Navajo 82-72 Saturday at home.

Ramah (2-2, 6-11) will host district leader Gallup Catholic Friday before playing at Tohajiilee Saturday in a pair of crucial district matchups.

"We put two good games back-to-back," Ramah coach Grant Clawson said. "We have the talent. We just have to get it together."

Against Quemado, Ramah outscored the home team 21-15 to win by eight points. Adriel Benally scored 24 points and John Gibbons added 14 for the Mustangs.

Quemado was led by Cody Green with 23 points, Chance Williams 12 and Jessie Lyons 10.

Against Alamo-Navajo, Ramah outscored the visitors 27-14 in the key third period for the win.

The Mustangs had four in double digits with John Gibbons with 18 points, Kerry Chicharello 13, Jace Blea 12 and Adriel
Benally 11 each.

Alamo-Navajo had Jordan Piasso with 23 points, Kirk Piasso 22 and Nikee Secatro 10.

Ramah shut down the Piasso duo with Jordan scoring only four more points in the second half and Kirk adding just eight
points in the second half after the pair combined for 33 points in the first half.

| Top |


To' Hajiilee Chapter renews casino drive

Jim Maniaci
Diné Bureau

WINDOW ROCK — The eastern-most Navajo satellite reservation launched its latest attempt at economic development on Monday by introducing a resolution to begin negotiating a gambling contract with New Mexico.

And although U.S. President's Day this coming Monday will be a holiday for the Navajo Nation, a handful of people in the Legislative Branch will be working because of the To' Hajiilee project and worry over the plague of Congressional continuing resolutions that are short-changing tribal departments funded by U.S. contracts and grants...

| Top |




New sheriff accused of seeking perks

Joe Kolb
Staff Writer

GALLUP — Felix Begay has been in office as McKinley County Sheriff for a little over one month and he's already making an impression in the community although not with his law enforcement abilities.

Begay was quoted in an Feb.4 issue of the Independent as saying: "We need to be nice to people. You're going to need those people..."

| Top |




Rape victims could obtain morning after pill under House proposal

SANTA FE (AP) — Hospital emergency rooms would be required to offeremergency contraception to rape victims under legislation approved Monday by the House.

Supporters said emergency contraception could prevent unwanted pregnancies resulting from sexual assaults...

| Top |





Deaths

Myron Denetdale

TOHATCHI — Services for Myron Denetdale, 81, will be held at 10 a.m., Wednesday, Feb. 12 at Naschitti Christian Reformed Church. Pastor Phillip Destea will officiate. Burial will follow at Naschitti Community Cemetery.

Denetdale died Feb. 7 in Gallup. He was born Dec. 14, 1921 in Naschitti into the Red Running into Water People Clan for the Bitter Water People Clan.

Denetdale attended Tohatchi Boarding School, Rehoboth Christian School and Albuquerque Indian School. He was employed
with Rockwell International, and was a member of the National Republican Party and the Los Angeles Indian Club. His hobbies included jewelry making, watching basketball and football games.

Survivors include his wife, Virginia Denetdale of Tohatchi; daughter, Yvonne Denetdale of Tohatchi; brothers, Harrison Yazhe of Naschitti, Ernest Yazhe of Nageezi, Herbert Yazzie of Gallup and Albert Yazhe of Farmington; and sisters, Ethel Yazhe of Window Rock, Marie R. Begay and Evelyn Billy of Naschitti.

Denetdale was preceded in death by her parents, Elsie Bell and Bizazidesni Denetdale; brother, Silas Yazhe and Andrew
YazzieAndrew Yazzie and sister, Ella Eagleman.

Pallbearers will be Benjamin Billy, Dennison Billy, Roger Billy, Robert Lee Jr., Gregory Lee and Perry Yellowhair.

The family will receive friends and relatives after the burial services at the family residence, Tohatchi.

Cope Memorial Chapel is in charge of arrangements.

Hugh M. Plummer


COYOTE CANYON — Services for Hugh Plummer, 81, were held at 10 a.m., Saturday, Feb. 8 at the Christian Reformed Church, Tohatchi. Rev. Milton Shirleson officiated. Burial followed at Tohatchi Community Cemtery.

Plummer died Feb. 4 in Albuquerque. He was born Feb. 2, 1922 in Coyote Canyon.

Survivors include his wife, Marie E. Plummer of Coyote Canyon; sons, Wayne T. Plummer of Window Rock, Victor Plummer and Robert Plummer both of Shiprock; daughters, Corrina Goodman of Farmington, Gladys Silversmith of Tohatchi, Henrietta Lucero of Rio Rancho and Yvonne Plummer of Gallup; stepchildren Martha Lahti, Lucinda Clark, E.T. Largo, Judy Casaus, Claudette Torres and Jimmie Largo; brothers, Richard Plummer and Herman Plummer of Coyote Canyon, Marshall Plummer of Farmington, Abe Plummer of Tsaile, Ariz. and Ned Plummer Jr. of Naschitti; sisters, Sena P. Clark and Alice Barber of Coyote Canyon, Rita Jazzie of Yah Ta Hey and Pearl Begay of Tohatchi; 25 grandchildren and 31 great-grandchildren.

Plummer was preceded in death by his parents; son, Hugh Plummer Jr.; daughters, Penni Plummer-Goodman and Debbie Plummer-Tso; sister, Marlene Plummer and brothers, Harold Plummer and Edward O. Plummer.

Yolanda Chavez

CUBERO — Services for Yolanda Chavez, 56, will be held at 10 a.m., today at Our Lady of Light Church, Cubero. Deacon William P. Beaton officiated. Burial followed at Cubero Cemetery.

Chavez died Feb. 8 in Albuquerque. She was born Nov. 15, 1946 in San Fidel.

Survivors include her husband, Samuel Chavez Sr. of Cubero; sons, Orlando Chavez, Samuel Chavez Jr. and James Chavez; daughters, Francine Chavez and Brenda Chavez; brothers, Liberato Abeyta, Richard Abeyta, Ralph Abeyta and Edward Abeyta; sister, Adelaida Green; three grandchildren and one great-grandchild.

Chavez was preceded in death by her parents and sisters, Placida Gonzales and Prescilla Saavedra.

Pallbearers were Beth Chavez, Paula Chavez, Eileen Maestas, Mary Jane Montao, Donna Chavez and Annette Gonzales.

Guadalupe Ignacio Rodriguez

GALLUP — Services for Guadalupe Rodriguez, 65, will be announced at a later date.

Rodriguez died Feb. 9 in Gallup and was born Dec. 12, 1937 in Navajo, N.M.

Rollie Mortuary is in charge of arrangements.

| Top |



Contact the Gallup Independent

Please send the Gallup Independent feedback on this website and the paper in general.

E-mail: gallpind@cia-g.com

By mail:

The Independent
PO Box 1210 Gallup, NM 87305
500 N. 9th Gallup, NM 87301


| Home | Daily News | Archive | Classifieds | Subscribe |

All contents property of the Gallup Independent.
Any duplication or republication requires consent of the Gallup Independent.
Feel free to send any questions or comments to gallpind@cia-g.com