Gallup firefighters carry a stretcher Tuesday with the body of a woman found in a ditch across the street from McKinley County Adult Detention Center in Gallup. An autopsy will be performed to determine the cause of death, but investigators have not ruled out foul play. Police would not release the woman's name Tuesday, pending notification of relatives. A passerby noticed the body about noon and flagged down a police car.

Photo by Jeff Jones

 

Wednesday
February 16
2000

( selected stories )

| Feb 15 | Feb 14 | Weekend | Feb 11 |
Feb 10

— Contents —

Potato plant pending; money projections rosy

Targets of recall in Window Rock say they may run again

Navajo cops investigate 3 murders

Tuba City avoids first round letdown


Potato plant pending; money projections rosy

Bill Donovan
Diné Bureau

GALLUP — Navajo Nation officials are expecting to make a decision within the next three weeks on the future of the long-delayed potato processing plant near Shiprock.

Larry Foster, chief aide to Navajo Nation President Kelsey Begaye, talking on this and other key issues facing tribal government, said Tuesday the president's office is waiting for the delivery of an investment analysis now being done on the potato plant.

"That analysis is supposed to be here this week," he said. Once the analysis arrives, Begaye and his staff will study it to learn whether the project is still financially viable.

The tribe has been looking at a proposal by the R. D. Offuit Co. since 1987 that would develop a plant to convert potatoes grown by the Navajo Agricultural Products Industries into potato chips and other products.

While the project has the support of almost all members of the Navajo Nation Council, negotiations have stalled over the question of tribal sovereignty and where disputes will be settled in tribal or state courts.

The project has been stalled so long that Begaye has asked that the feasibility study, now more than five years old, be updated to see whether anything has changed in the market to make the plan less viable.

Foster stressed in the past that this move doesn't indicate the tribe is getting "cold feet," but only that the tribe wants to be sure the market is still there before it invests tens of millions of dollars into the project.

Revenue projections

Foster also said the president's office probably won't know until late February or early March what the early projections are for tribal revenue for the next fiscal year.

By this time last year, tribal officials were aware that projections indicated a shortfall of some $20 million for this year's budget. But a number of factors including a robust oil market resulted in no shortfall occurring when the budget was finally approved.

"While we haven't received any figures yet, our understanding is that the situation this year will be a far better one than we were facing at this time last year," he said.

In fact, the oil industry is continuing to see high prices at the pump, which means extra royalties for the tribe.

Officials for the tribe's Office of Management and Budget, which oversees the preparation of the annual budget, said in the past that preliminary projections for next year's budget would have already been made by this time.

But the controller's office was asked this year to delay giving out preliminary figures until it had more accurate projections. If the projections are given too early, tribal budget officials said, the tribe arrives at a budget that is unrealistic and results in tribal program directors developing budgets that by May or June have no basis in reality.

Foster said the tribe is still seeing fuel tax collections, now in their fourth month, far exceeding expectations.

"We projected an annual income of $10 million a year, and we're doing better than that so far," he said, adding that prices at gas stations throughout the United States have been high and are expected to go even higher as summer approaches, which means that royalties to the tribe will also be going up.

| Top |


Targets of recall in Window Rock say they may run again

Bill Donovan
Diné Bureau

GALLUP — Larry Foster, the subject of a failed recall movement, said Tuesday this hasn't dampened his spirits about being a member of the Window Rock Unified School District Board.

In the next few weeks, he will make a decision on whether he will run again for election. He says he probably will run.

Elmer Milford, who was also the subject of a recall and whose term expires this year, is leaning toward running again, school officials said.

"I have received a lot of support and a lot of calls to keep going," said Foster, who is also the chief aide for Navajo Nation President Kelsey Begaye.

The two board members, along with Pauline Begay whose term will not expire this year were the subject of a recall by the Concerned Citizens for Better Education. The recall failed when the tribe's election office threw out for various reasons 56 percent of the 520 signatures submitted by the group.

"If you look at the number of valid signatures that the group had, it was only some 7 percent, which meant that a lot of voters didn't support the recall effort," Foster said.

The recall movement began after the three refused to renew the contracts of three popular principals last summer, a decision all three board members said they would do over again.

Foster went further, stating he and the other board members were committed to making decisions they believed "were in the best interest of students" within the district.

Begay, in a statement released last week, said the recall effort demonstrated several things to her.

"First, some of us as Navajos are not educated enough to know what a recall petition is, what its major purpose is or why the petition is being circulated, especially for those who only speak the Navajo language," she said.

She said the rejection of so many signatures also indicates that many Navajos need to learn how to fill out the petition correctly and know whether their signatures will be valid. For example, many Navajos who lived outside the district boundaries and who were not registered to vote signed the petitions.

Both Foster and Begay were critical of staff members within the school district who got involved in the petition drives.

"The staff should be grateful they have a job," Begay said. "Their focus should be to provide the best quality education to the students ... We cannot afford to spend our energy on something that negates our goal of education."

Officials for the citizens' group said their efforts to remove the three board members are not over. If either Milford or Foster decides to run for re-election, the officials said, it will make a concentrated effort to get them defeated at the election polls.

| Top |


Navajo cops investigate 3 murders

Jim Maniaci
Diné Bureau

WINDOW ROCK — A 79-year-old Tuba City woman died Tuesday after being stabbed in the chest. Navajo tribal police also reported Tuesday the 10th traffic fatality on the reservation this year as well as two other homicides in the Fort Defiance and Crownpoint areas.

In the Tuba City homicide, emergency medical technicians trying to revive Glennis Singer discovered the stab wound.

The woman was found on the floor of her home by a daughter who called the Tuba City Police District around 5:45 a.m.

Navajo police believe Singer was attacked more than three hours before being found. Her home is about one-quarter of a mile south of the Arizona Public Service Co.'s electric power substation.

Navajo officers and detectives took three Tuba City men ages 36, 59 and 65 into custody for questioning in the case but did not file charges against them.

Other murders

Two additional homicides occurred last week in Fort Defiance and Crownpoint.

Freddie Harvey, 53, of Yah-Ta-Hey died of massive face and head injuries Friday night or Saturday morning.

A woman went to the Indian Health Service hospital in Fort Defiance about 6:15 a.m. Saturday to report a man bleeding in the street at Old Red Lake Road and Roanhouse Drive. Taken to the hospital, Harvey was pronounced dead on arrival.

The Window Rock Police District report listed the case as alcohol and drug related, but gave no details.

Shortly before noon Saturday, the Crownpoint Police District received a call about a dead man found near a Native American Mission about one mile west of McKinley County Road 61.

Police found a man believed to be Harry Notah, 40, who lived three miles east of Thoreau High School. He reportedly left home the night before for a drinking spree. A man passing through the site found Notah's beaten body and contacted the mission. Notah's mother made a tentative identification, but confirmation was pending.

Police believe Notah fought with his killer because a shattered club and blood were found at the scene.

Officers found a drunken man nearby. They consider him a suspect, but did not arrest him.

Traffic death

The traffic fatality occurred before 1 a.m. Friday, one mile north of the Sanostee Chapter House on BIA Route 5010. Once again, Navajo police said alcohol was involved.

Tommy Nabahe, 45, who lived three miles west of Newcomb, died when his southbound vehicle went off the road into a wash, hit a culvert in a steep bank and toppled onto its right side.

The Shiprock Police District report said alcoholic beverages were found inside the vehicle.

Another victim, James Dayzie, 45, who lives about 3.25 miles northwest of the Newcomb Chapter House, survived. He was taken to the Indian Health Service hospital in Shiprock.

Police did not say which man was the driver, but they believe the driver fell asleep at the steering wheel.

| Top |


Tuba City avoids first round letdown

Santiago Ramos
Staff Sports Writer

FLAGSTAFF, Ariz. — There was a surprisingly high mortality rate among area boys basketball teams during Tuesday's opening round of the 3A Boys State Championships while in the 3A Girls State Championships all four girls teams survived and advanced with impressive performances.

Ganado and Monument Valley, the 3A Enchantment No. 3 and No. 4 seeds, made quick exits Tuesday afternoon at the Northern Arizona University Skydome.

Ganado was disposed off easily by West No. 2 seed Seton Catholic 69-45 and Monument Valley was unable to avoid the first-round jinx for the third year in a row as the No. 4 Mustangs were also whipped by West's top seed Fountain Hills 73-48...

| Top |


Death may be due to fall

Tanya Brazil
Staff Writer

GALLUP — The body of a Gallup woman, who most likely fell after a night of drinking, was found Tuesday morning lying face down in the arroyo across from the Magistrate Court on Boardman Drive.

The deceased, Ruthie Clawson, 66, was spotted by an unknown male who informed court employees that a female individual was lying in the bottom of the arroyo near the court, police said.

Police said a court clerk waved down a passing police car and showed Patrolman Owen Pena the body at the bottom of the ditch...

| Top |


Shelly accuses Democrats of breaking rules

Zarana Sanghani
Staff Writer

GALLUP — At a meeting of the local Democratic Party Tuesday night, McKinley County Commissioner Ben Shelly said he would protest any action the group took because he thought the meeting was invalid.

Four days before the meeting, Shelly had asked New Mexico Party Chairwoman Diane Denish to intercede and postpone the meeting.

He said at the meeting and in a letter to Denish that he believed the public, especially the Native American public, was not properly notified of the party's meeting...

| Top |


Gallup-Rio triple OT game worth the price

Robert Arrieta
Staff Sports Writer

GALLUP — For fans who bought tickets to Saturday night's Gallup boys basketball game, it was a bargain price for a great game.

The Bengals hosted district rival Rio Grande and, for the second time this season, played a close game.

Both teams were so evenly matched that the game could not be settled in four quarters, or an extra period, or another extra period. In fact it took three overtimes for Rio Grande to finally slip past the Bengals, 63-60...

| Top |


Cibola may put records on microfilm

Tom Purdom
Staff Writer

GRANTS — Fearing that a fire could destroy county records now stored in a multitude of cardboard boxes, County Manager Bob Ortiz is asking some questions.

When he began talking about the situation at the Cibola County Commission meeting recently, he started with simple words: "I want to tell you about a problem."

Since Cibola County was created in 1981, records have been stored in cardboard boxes in a county-owned building...

| Top |


Three admit to drugs
Judge's son gets jail term

Jim Maniaci
Diné Bureau

CHINLE, Ariz. — The son of a tribal judge was given a year in tribal jail after pleading guilty to charges stemming from a police drug raid earlier this month.

Two of the others who were arrested have also pleaded guilty.

A total of five people were arrested in the raid conducted by Chinle police on Feb. 6. No court complaint was filed against one of the five because he was wanted on a judge's bench warrant for another crime...

| Top |


Special session looms for N.M. Legislature

Walter Howerton Jr.
Santa Fe Bureau

SANTA FE — The New Mexico legislative session is supposed to end at noon Thursday, but don't count on it.

Gov. Gary Johnson said Tuesday he does not believe the Legislature can work out a budget he can sign by the time the clock runs out. He sees too many problems in the budget being considered by the Senate to sign it.

If the Senate budget reached Johnson's desk, an aide to the governor said Monday, it would set a "land speed record" for being vetoed...

| Top |


Deaths

Freddie James Hardy

BLACK HAT — Services for Freddie James Hardy, 53, will be held at 10 a.m. Thursday, Feb. 17, at the Good Shepherd Mission in Fort Defiance, Ariz. The Right Rev. Stephen Plumber will officiate. Burial will follow on family land in Black Hat.

Visitation will be held at 9 a.m. Thursday, Feb. 17, at the church one hour before services.

Hardy died Feb. 12 in Fort Defiance. He was born Dec. 19, 1946, into the Edge Water People Clan for the Towering House People Clan.

Hardy completed high school in Fort Defiance. He attended two years of trade school in Dallas, Texas. He was an archer with Navajo Community College. He was also a Vietnam veteran; after serving two terms he returned to the Black Hat area where he became a rancher, taking care of sheep.

Survivors include his father, Tom Hardy and stepmother, Margaret Hardy, both of Fort Defiance; brothers, Tommy Hardy, Jonathan Jose, Timothy Hardy, Wayne Hardy, all of Fort Defiance, Andy Hardy of Tohatchi and Joe Jose of Mesa, Ariz.; sisters, Cindy Hardy of Mesa and Arlene Hardy of St. Michaels, Ariz.

Hardy was preceded in death by his mother, Helen Hardy, and brother, Ronald Hardy.

Pallbearers will be Tommy Hardy, Joe Jose, Jonathan Jose, Timothy Hardy, Wayne Hardy and Andy Hardy.
Tse Bonito Mortuary is in charge of the arrangements.

Laura Rachel Bertinetti

GALLUP — Services for Laura Rachel "Laurie Rae" Bertinetti, 16, will be held at 10 a.m. Thursday, Feb. 17, at The Door-Gallup Christian Center. Pastor Gregory Johnson will officiate.

Bertinetti died Feb. 14 in Gallup. She was born March 2, 1983, in Gallup.

Bertinetti attended Gallup McKinley County Schools through the ninth grade. She was then home-schooled to present. She was involved with her church youth group where she participated in music, drama, puppetry and children's ministries. She has also been a caregiver to her paternal grandparents for the past year.

Survivors include her parents, Jerry and Cheri Bertinetti of Gallup; sister, Sarah June Bertinetti of Gallup; grandparents, Herbert and June Harper of Camp Verde, Ariz., and Helen D. Bertinetti of Gallup.

Bertinetti was preceded in death by her grandfather, Dominic Bertinetti.

Pallbearers will be Dan Johnson, Nic Montoya, Eddy Jaramillo, Ben Shirley, Nathan Tafoya and Gerald Harper.

The family will receive relatives and friends after the service in the fellowship hall of the Gallup Christian Center.

Cope Memorial Chapel of Gallup is in charge of arrangements.

Eleanor J. Raum


GALLUP — Services for Eleanor J. Raum, 59, will be held at 10 a.m. Thursday, Feb. 17, at St. Isabel Mission in Lukachukai, Ariz. Father Caron, O.F.M., will officiate. Burial will follow on family land in Tsaile.

Raum died Feb. 12 in Tse Bonito. She was born Aug. 18, 1940, in Wheatfields, Ariz., into the Salt People Clan for the Big Water People Clan.

Raum attended Inter-Mountain Indian School. She was a homemaker. Her hobbies included beadwork.

Survivors include her sons, Frankie Spencer of Wheatfields, Ariz., Raymond Spencer of Tse Bonito, and Donald Spencer of Fort Wingate; daughters, Deborah Bia of Sawmill, Sophia Todecheene of Gallup, and Francine Spencer of Grants; brothers, Homer K. Brown, Otis K. Brown, both of Tsaile, Ariz., and Leroy K. Brown of Gallup, Johnny Brown of Dallas, Texas; 13 grandchildren and one great-grandchildren.

Raum was preceded in death by her husband, Jack Raum; daughter, Raymond Spencer; parents, Tom and Bah Brown.

Pallbearers will be Darryl Todecheene, Raymond Spencer, Donald Spencer, Roger Whitehair, Leroy Whitehair and Anslem Bia Jr.

The family will receive relatives and friends at the Tsaile/Wheatfield Chapter House.

Tse Bonito Mortuary is in charge of the arrangements.

| Top |



All contents property of the Gallup Independent.
Any duplication or republication requires consent of the Gallup Independent.
Feel free to send any questions or comments to gallpind@cia-g.com
E-mail the webmaster at martyr_dom@hotmail.com