Torn esophagus, man's death prompts lawsuit
Tanya Brazil
Staff Writer
GALLUP When Quentin Newsom died he had enough drugs in his
system to knock him cold. But he also had a badly torn esophagus caused
by medical personnel who allegedly rammed his dental bridge down his
throat trying to revive him.
According to the official autopsy report by the Office of the Medical
Investigator in Albuquerque, it might have been a combination of the
two that killed him.
Now his family has filed a civil suit in district court alleging medical
negligence by the Gallup Fire Department Emergency Medical Services
and Med Star.
The lawsuit alleges employees from the two agencies were inadequately
trained in the use of the oesophageal/tracheal combitube a device
used to clear the airway and help the patient breathe.
Employees were negligent, the lawsuit states, because prior to inserting
the combitube, they failed to check and remove a partial bridge that
was in the patient's mouth and used "excessive force" during
its insertion, causing the the patient's esophagus to be perforated
when the bridge was forced down his esophagus.
Vern Newsom, the brother of the deceased, said it was a physician
who initially told the family that tremendous force must have been
used during insertion of the combitube in order to push the dental
bridge that far down the esophagus.
But by then it was too late, he said, hours had passed since his brother
had been treated by emergency medical personnel and initially was
taken to Rehoboth McKinley Christian Hospital where drugs were administered
to reverse the comatose condition caused by the heroin overdose.
His brother had been revived from the overdose, he said, but because
he continued to struggle and had injured his head when he fell during
the overdose, doctors sedated him so they could do a cat scan.
The cat scan results were normal, he said, but his brother was having
difficulty breathing so doctors performed a series of other tests.
Seven hours had already passed when an X-ray indicated the presence
of a large tear in the esophagus where a foreign object had been lodged,
according to the autopsy report.
Doctors then determined Quentin Newsom should be airlifted to University
Hospital in Albuquerque, he said, and family members began preparing
to go with him everyone except his father, Howard Newsom, whose dialysis
treatment would prevent him from making the trip.
Vern Newsom said his father wanted to go to Albuquerque so badly but
all he could do was wait by the phone for news about his son.
What made matters worse, he said, was that family members only were
allowed to see his brother for a few moments while he was at RMCH
after the warden gave detention officers an order to restrict the
visits.
But Cody Graham, the warden at the McKinley County Adult Detention
Center, denied giving an order to prevent the family from seeing Quentin
Newsom and said he typically does not prohibit family from visiting
inmates in cases of serious illness.
Restrictions on visits usually occur for security reasons, he said,
but the inmate clearly was not in any condition to go anywhere and
would not have been considered a security risk.
Periodically the family called his father from Albuquerque, he said,
but each time the prognosis was worse and each time the phone would
ring, his father would brace himself for more bad news.
Once in Albuquerque, doctors confirmed two large cuts in Quentin Newsom's
esophagus and told the family they would operate.
Doctors explained the seriousness of the surgery and told the family
they were not optimistic about his chance at recovery, that too much
time had elapsed nearly 12 hours according to the autopsy report since
the initial injury.
By this time, Vern Newsom said, body acids had seeped through his
brother's system and literally were eating him alive.
When Quentin Newsom came out of surgery three to four hours later,
he was covered in plastic and breathing with the assistance of a machine.
Doctors told the family he probably would not make it through the
night, that a lack of oxygen had caused him to become brain dead and
it would be best to turn off the machine.
Vern Newsom said his brother wanted help for his drug problem, that
he told him he was tired of living this way and wanted to change.
He said his brother saw that sobriety was working for him and was
starting to believe it might work for him too.
As a recovering addict, Vern Newsom understood his brother's
struggle with heroin addiction and had made arrangements for him to
go to a long-term treatment center.
He said his brother was excited about the idea of going to the drug
treatment center, as ordered by District Court Judge Joseph Rich upon
completion of his one-year sentence.
Quentin Newsom was not an angel. He had been designated by the State
of New Mexico as a habitual criminal after being convicted of three
prior felonies and has an extensive list of misdemeanors. In the 1980s,
he had been convicted of armed robbery and felony larceny in McKinley
County and for attempted contraband introduction into prison in Valencia
County.
Since then, he had developed an extensive list of misdemeanors prior
to his last arrest on felony charges of robbery and tampering with
evidence, the latter stemming from an alleged purse snatching in the
Wal-Mart parking lot.
As his brother awaited transfer to prison on this latest
charge, Vern Newsom said he tried to cheer him up but he became despondent
as months passed by and he watched people who had been sentenced after
him being transferred.
The jail simply was waiting on an order from the District Attorney's
office, Vern Newsom said, but no one at the office would respond to
his repeated calls.
Vern Newsom and his father blame District Attorney Mary Helen Baber
and former Assistant District Attorney Michael Sanchez for deliberately
delaying his transfer because of their personal animosity toward the
Newsom family.
They said they believe the District Attorney's office is biased, unable
to do its job and directly contributed to Quentin Newsom's death.
"Granted, Quentin had his problems, but no one's to say where
he could have ended up,"Vern Newsom said. "He could have
straightened out. Is that a reason to let him die?"
Baber said she does not believe the deceased held the same animosity
toward her as his family does, that he wrote her a few nice letters
after she immediately dismissed one of his cases when she took office.
Sanchez, who now works for the District Attorney's Office in Las Vegas,
NM, denied doing anything to prevent Quentin Newsom from being transferred
and explained that there simply was a back up in paperwork at that
time due to the office being shorthanded.
"We don't pick names out of the phone book,"he said. "Quentin
was a career criminal, that's the bottom line. We didn't pick on him.
We just prosecuted him for what he did. If he had stopped committing
crimes, we would have stopped prosecuting him."
It was not the system that destroyed Quentin Newsom, he said, but
rather his drug usage which made him vulnerable to have to steal to
support his habit and inevitably killed him.
But Vern Newsom and his father still believe that he would still be
alive had he been transferred to prison more quickly and given an
opportunity for treatment.
"It's true Quentin is not the greatest guy in the world,"Howard
Newsom said. "He was sentenced to do his punishment. But he wasn't
sentenced to the death penalty and that's what it ended up being."
He said the family has filed the civil suit on behalf of his deceased
son's 8-year-old daughter and to bring attention to and hopefully
prevent the kind of incompetence by emergency personnel that inevitably
caused his son's death.
| Top |
Descheny, school board, miss the point
on teen health care
Walter Howerton Jr.
Managing Editor
Birds do it, bees do it, even teen-agers at Thoreau and Crownpoint
high schools do it no matter what Annie Descheny and the rest of the
Gallup-McKinley County School Board think.
Last week I found myself writing about the kinds of stupid stuff teen-agers
do (you remember THAT party). Now I am forced to give equal time to
the kinds of stupid things adults do, in particular the school board's
decision to shut down health clinic operations for teen-agers at Thoreau
and Crownpoint high schools because they didn't want anybody bringing
up words like condoms or sex education because it might give teen-agers
the wrong idea about "doing it" like they don't have ideas
already.
Sometimes stupidity reaches epidemic proportions among
elected officials, though the voters, especially those who were refused
the right to speak out at Monday night's school board meeting, can
cure that at the voting booth on Feb. 6.
But let's talk about official stupidity first. We'll get to the democracy
part later.
Here are some facts of life (so, listen up Ms. Descheny):
Teen-agers already know about sex. Sort of. What they don't know can
hurt them and other people, too. Sexual urges happen.
Sexually transmitted diseases happen in record numbers. Undiagnosed
(and sometimes hidden) pregnancies happen. And even in the best of
circumstances babies happen, too.
And here are some more facts of life:
Other things happen to teen-agers, too. Some are depressed and suicidal.
Some are chronically ill. Some have drug and alcohol problems. Some
are beginning to suffer from diabetes. Some have precancerous lesions
that could become cancer if they go untreated for a year or two (more
than you would think, according to physicians). Sometimes they have
health problems they just won't talk to their parents about.
And there is one more fact of local life:
It is a long way to medical care from almost anywhere around here.
It takes time or transportation that many parents don't always have
to take a child to the doctor.
Six years ago, Indian Health Service doctors began providing full
service health care to students at Crownpoint and Thoreau high schools.
They were right there in the school. They weren't family. They weren't
judgmental. Teens were comfortable coming to see them about awkward
problems.
In the six years before they started 220 babies were born to teen-age
mothers at the Crownpoint hospital alone; in the six years since,
only 142 have been reported. That is a decrease that should make us
all feel pretty good (even those like school board member Descheny
who spout the tired old stuff about "babies having babies"
then vote so more babies probably will be having babies. Go figure).
But the two clinics have not been all about babies. They have been
about all of those other emotional and physical health problems teen-agers
have, too. Six years' worth of teen-agers have received help they
never would have received otherwise.
Some of them are healthy and some no doubt are alive because some
caring doctors came to them, took them seriously, listened to what
they had to say and gave them the help they needed.
What IHS doctors wanted from the school board on Monday night was
to expand the services they could offer. They wanted to be able to
dispense medicines, treat serious health problems and educate teen-agers
about matters that might affect their health.
That probably would include sex education and might include contraception.
Descheny apparently choked on the idea of doctors dispensing condoms.
"What!" she said. "If we give them condoms they
might get the idea it is OK to use 'em." Or something like that.
So, Descheny quickly and emotionally moved as a "mother and grandmother"
(whatever that had to do with anything) to deny
Navajo children needed and convenient health care, apparently just
so no one would think that she thinks "doing it" is OK.
Pssssssst. Ms. Descheny. I hate to tell you, but they already have
the idea it is OK to do it, with or without condoms or medical
advice or your blessing. It is impossible to live in the U.S. (or
even on the sovereign Navajo Nation part of it) and NOT get the
idea that it is OK.
Go to the movies; go to the mall; watch some television; listen to
a few CDs; look at Britney Spears belly button; read a
magazine (almost any magazine); go to a clothing store; look at a
Barbie doll; check out the perfume, cologne, deodorant, body
care department.
Sex are us, Ms. Descheny. At least that is what the kids see when
they look around them. Maybe you should take a look around
and get a grip on reality before you get on your "mother and
grandmother" soapbox next time.
It is fine to oppose premarital sex, especially among those too young
to understand all of the implications of what they are
doing. From what we hear that is what doctors treating the children
at those high schools did anyway. They said wait. They said
grow up. They said talk to your parents about this. But they understood
to whom they were speaking. They were speaking to
children in need of help. So, for six years, they helped them. And
parents did sign letters allowing their children access to the
program.
But no more.
No more health care for students at Crownpoint and Thoreau (unless
you count sports physicals and bad colds). That's what
Descheny wanted and that's what she got. The school board killed the
whole health program.
Not only that, in a dazzling display of the way democracy works, they
did it without allowing any of those most affected by it
students, parents, health care professionals, educators and other
citizens to say a word about it.
Supporters of the clinics had been invited by the board to show up
to present the case for keeping and expanding the clinics.
And they did. But they never got the chance to say anything. Ms. Descheny
said she saw no reason to discuss it, so they didn't.
The board cut off debate. They board voted 4-0 (Manuel Shirelson abstained).
They shut 'em up and shut 'em down in record
time.
The message to the students at Crownpoint and Thoreau couldn't have
been more clear and it was a message that had nothing to
do with condoms or whether or not it was OK to use them.
The message was: Health care. Who cares? Especially not the school
board, those elected to look after your interest (at least as long
as it doesn't get in the way of their interest. Right, Ms. Descheny?).
It's no wonder our children sometimes don't trust us. They aren't
that stupid.
All together now. Birds do it. Bees do it. You know the rest. Let
the school board hear you. I'll bet even Annie Descheny can learn
to quit singing the same old song.
| Top |
Grants man points gun at woman
Tara Drolma
Staff Writer
GRANTSA 19-year old Milan man thought he was being cool when
he cocked a handgun and pointed it at a woman and her two children.
But he found out it wasn't very cool as they left the supermarket,
and he was arrested.
About 8:30 p.m. last Friday Herbert Nelson Jr., 19, of Milan was arrested
and charged with three counts of aggravated assault with a deadly
weapon for allegedly frightening Helen Gabaldon and her two children
in the parking lot of the Milan Supermarket.
His companion, Sherry Woods, 22, also from Milan was charged with
contributing to the delinquency of a minor.
Gabaldon told Milan Police Officer Pat Salazar she and her children
were in their truck when they saw a man approach his car, then take
a gun out of his pants. He cocked the gun, looked at Gabaldon and
then laughed. She said the car was gold and had a lot of damage on
the right side and one window was taped up. She had memorized the
license plate and she said the car drove off in the direction of Grants.
After reporting the incident, Gabaldon went to the McDonalds in Grants
where she saw the gold car in the parking lot. She called the police
and Salazar and two other officers, Tomas Archuleta and Adrian Molina
went to the fast food restaurant.
Salazar said Nelson was walking around the front his
car when the three patrol cars drove up. Because the officers knew
he was armed, for their protection, they did what is called a felony
stop. The drew their guns and ordered Nelson and Woods to stop and
put their hands up. Then they had them raise their shirts above their
waists and turn in circles so officers could determine if they were
armed. After doing that they were told to lie on the ground and they
were handcuffed.
When Salazar searched the car he found two six-packs of beer, a bat,
a large knife, and the gun, a Black Marksman Repeater BB gun. Salazar
said this type of gun looks just like his police revolver except it
is black. He said he could understand why Gabaldon had been frightened
by it.
Nelson and Woods were taken back to the police station and questioned
before they were booked and taken to jail. Woods refused to talk with
the officers, but Nelson told them the car belonged to a friend of
Woods' mother and they had taken it. They found the gun on the front
seat of the car. At the supermarket Nelson slipped the gun into the
front of his trousers before they entered the store where Wood's bought
the beer for him.
When he walked outside he said the gun had begun to slip down so he
pulled it out, looked over at the truck where Galbadon and her children
were, cocked the gun, and laughed. Salazar said he told him he did
it to act cool.
In another case, Milan police officers took a report for aggravated
assault with a deadly weapon. They are looking for Donicio Sanchez
for allegedly threatening 20-year-old Victor Abeita with a knife.
Sgt. Jerry Stephens of Milan Police Department said he has a case
under investigation that involves a woman who has been receiving threatening
phone calls. For several weeks the woman received harassing calls
from an unidentified man. Then the man began to threaten her and her
family. If the person is caught he can be charged with using a telephone
to terrify, intimidate, threaten, harass, or annoy, which is a misdemeanor.
| Top |
Bengal girls downslide continues
Michael Peretti
Staff Sports Writer
The Gallup Lady Bengals suffered their fifth loss in as many games
Friday night when they lost to Sandia 50-38 in Albuquerque.
The Bengals, which drop to 4-5, led for most of the first half but
foul trouble kept their main players out for the better part of the
second half. Still Gallup battled with Sandia and both teams went
back and forth until late in the fourth when the Matadors got a six-point
lead, forcing Gallup to foul.
Gallup coach John Lomasney said that his team was able to compete
with the Sandia team, and that the only problem he
thought the team had was all of the fouls they picked up.
"We had to take our height out and they went inside on us,"
Lomasney said. "Our starting five against their starting five,
we won. Most of my team was on the bench the second half and they
pulled away."
Gallup did not have any players foul out, but had five players with
three or more fouls. Regular starters Vanessa Hubbard, Roberta Tahe
and Tanya Bailey all missed some playing time with four fouls. The
Bengals committed 21 fouls in the game.
The two teams set the pace for the game early, scoring only 10 points
combined in the first five minutes. Gallup got their biggest lead
of the game at 17-9 in the first quarter but Sandia came right back.
The Matadors scored the next seven points, hitting a three-pointer
at the buzzer at the end of the first quarter. They then scored the
first two baskets of the second quarter.
Shooting 4-of-6 from three-point range in the first half kept the
Lady Bengals ahead of the Matadors, but the Bangals cooled down in
the second half. Gallup hit one three to start off the third quarter,
but then would go dry, missing the rest of their attempts in the game.
The Matadors took the a 27-26 lead in the third quarter when Kim Neff
hit a pair of free throws and trailed only one more time
in the game. Sandia trailed for the last time 29-27 but retook the
lead seconds later when Judy Vogt hit a free throw and Lindsey Arndt
hit a layup.
The Bengal defense held Sandia to eight points in the third quarter,
but they could not get their offense going, only scoring four in the
period.
Sandia began a 13-1 run at the end of the third quarter which continued
at the beginning of the fourth to take a 40-30 lead.
Meanwhile, Gallup continued to have problems on offense in the fourth,
only scoring eight points. But the Bengals were still able to keep
the Matadors within eight for most of the second half, but with four
minutes left in the game, Sandia slowly began to pull away.
The Lady Bengals pulled to 41-36 but the Matadors went into a stall
offense forcing Gallup to foul.
The Matadors, who were in the one-and-one two minutes into the fourth
quarter hit 9-of-11 in the period to hold on to the win.
Dawn Hobgood scored all six of her points in the fourth quarter and
Kim Neff added 4-of-6 from the line for four points. Judy Vogt was
the only other Matador to score in the fourth, hitting a jumper midway
through the quarter.
Gallup finished the game shooting 3-for-9 from the field in the final
four minutes of the fourth quarter. The Matadors
outrebounded Gallup late in the game and forced the Bengals to turn
the ball over four times late in the game.
Gallup was led by Sunny St. Clair, who finished with 14 points. Christine
Begay scored six points, all in the first quarter. Iris Wilson hit
2-of-3 from three-point range to finish with six as well.
Sandia was led by Judy Vogt, finishing with 18. Lindsey Arndt scored
11 and Kim Neff had 10. Dawn Hobgood finished with nine, all in the
fourth quarter and five coming on 5-of-5 free throw shooting.
Sandia shot 20-of-27 from the free throw line while Gallup shot 7-of-14.
Gallup turned the ball over 11 times and had 10 takeaways. The Lady
Bengals scored 17 points in the first quarter and then scored 21 points
the rest of the game.
Gallup was outrebounded by Sandia 27-19.
Gallup shot 5-of-11 from three-point range, Wilson and St.Clair both
hitting two. St.Clair made one of her threes and Wilson hit both of
hers in the first half. The only other three came from Vanessa Hubbard
in the first quarter.
The Bengals will attempt to end their losing streak tonight as they
take on Eldorado in Albuquerque.
| Top |
Venture looks for ways to produce Navajo
hogans
TUCSON, Ariz. (AP) The demand, the raw materials and the motivation
to mass produce traditional Navajo hogans have been around for some
time. But until recently no one had found a way to harness them at
once.
Now an organization sponsored by Northern Arizona University, working
with the Navajo Nation and U.S. Forest Service, has developed a way
to make a better hogan, octagonal dwellings often used in ceremonies,
and produce a number of spinoff benefits in the process.
If the plans by Indigenous Community Enterprises work out, they could
provide new jobs, create a new technology to use wood normally considered
scrap, produce a new market, and maybe create an industry in northern
Arizona.
Tribal officials estimate that at least 30,000 hogans (pronounced
ho-GAHNS) are needed to ease a severe housing shortage on the Navajo
Reservation, home to 200,000 Navajos...
| Top |
Conflict is charged over potato issue
Larry Di Giovanni
Staff Writer
WINDOW ROCK Tribal council plans to make a $20 million potato
processing plant capital investment came to a halt Friday.
Friday was the second and final day of a Navajo Nation Council special
session. The Navajo Agricultural Products Industry proposed project
stood as the main agenda item.
The resulting resolution, tabled until the regular winter session
next month, was preceded by a showdown on the council floor involving
section 3748 of the Navajo Ethics in Government Law. Shiprock Delegate
Wallace Charley confronted Hogback Delegate Ervin Keeswood Sr. on
a possible conflict of interest.
The vote to table the $20 million expenditure was 34-21 and no abstentions,
with Charley voting "yes" and Keeswood "no..."
| Top |
Union official hopes to oust DeLaO from board
Bill Donovan
GALLUP The top official for the local school union is hoping
that at least one of the current members of the Gallup-McKinley
County School Board bites the dust in the upcoming elections.
Tom Payton, president of the McKinley County Federation of United
School Employees, said Joe DeLaO has been a thorn in the side of
the teachers and a hindrance to progress for the district since
he was elected four years ago.
"I've been advised by others that I shouldn't direct critical
comment against any individual school board member but in DeLaO's
case, it doesn't make any difference," Payton said. "He'll
be anti-teacher and anti-union as long as he is a member of the
school board."
DeLaO's position is one of three that will be on a school board
election ballot on Feb. 6. Other positions up for election are the
ones now held by Ken Holloway and Johnny R. Thompson...
| Top
|
FBI agents protest clemency request by Peltier
WASHINGTON (AP) Nearly 500 current and retired FBI agents marched
to the White House Friday in an unprecedented protest, opposing any
presidential clemency for an American Indian activist convicted of
killing two FBI men.
Carrying a "Never Forget" banner lettered in red, a line
of women stood two-by-two for the march to the White House gate with
a petition to President Clinton signed by 8,000 current and former
agents.
Secret Service agents at the White House gate rejected the envelope,
however, telling their fellow federal officers that no packages or
documents can be accepted for security reasons. The FBI agents planned
to mail the petition.
Susan Lloyd, an FBI field office spokeswoman who joined the protesters,
said the vast majority of those in the demonstration were active agents
who applied for the day off...
| Top
|
Opening records makes life easy, Hobbs police chief
says
SANTA FE (AP) Law enforcers were the biggest
scofflaws in a statewide survey of access to public records.
But Hobbs Police Chief Tony Knott says it's easier
to prop the door open than to keep shutting it. His stated policy:
Ask for public records and you will get them.
"We're responsible for enforcing the law,"
Knott said. "I think it's imperative that we follow the law."
In an audit by New Mexico newspapers to determine
how readily the public can get hold of public information, three
of every 10 requests for access to records were unsuccesful...
Deaths
Charles Kezele
GALLUP Services for Charles Kezele, 85, will be held at 11
a.m., Monday, Dec. 18 at the Sacred Heart Cathedral. Father Jim Walker
will officiate. Burial will follow at Sunset Memorial Park.
A rosary will be recited at 7 p.m., Sunday, Dec. 17 at Rollie Mortuary-Palm
Chapel.
Kezele died Dec. 13 in Albuquerque. He was born March 25, 1915 in
Heaton.
Kezele was a member of the Knights of Columbus and the VFW of Gallup
and the CFU Lodge #60.
Survivors include his wife, Helen Kezele of Gallup; son, Floyd Kezele
of Gallup; daughter, Charlene Iskra of Gallup; six
grandchildren and three great-grandchildren.
Kezele was preceded in death by parents, Mike and Katherine Kezele
and grandson.
Pallbearers will be I.D. Cato, Andre Martisik, Gary Mesich, Terry
Mesich, Walt Peters, Floyd Senoski, and Steve
Tomljanovich.
Donations may be made to Gallup Catholic School, 515 Park Ave.
Rollie Mortuary is in charge of arrangements.
Frances Sardo
CASAMERO LAKE Services for Frances Sardo, 71, will be held
at 10 a.m. Monday, Dec. 18, at Assembly of God Church, Prewitt. Sarah
H. Begay will officiate. Burial will follow at the community cemetery,
Thoreau.
Sardo died Dec. 12 in Gallup. She was born May 15, 1929, in Prewitt
into the Hairy People Clan for the Meadow People Clan.
Sardo was a rug weaver, bead worker and homemaker.
Survivors include her sons, Buck Begay and Randy Sardo, both of Prewitt;
daughters, Lucita Sardo and Lucy Begay of Prewitt; brother, Jimmy
Chaco of Prewitt; 10 grandchildren and 14 great-grandchildren.
Pallbearers will be Randy Sardo, Ronald Sardo, Jimmy Platero Jr.,
Larry Martinez, Eddie Pablo and Nelbert Yazzie.
Cope Memorial Chapel is in charge of arrangements.
Contact the Gallup
Independent
Please send the Gallup Independent feedback on
this website and the paper in general.
E-mail: gallpind@cia-g.com
By mail:
The Independent
PO Box 1210 Gallup, NM 87305
500 N. 9th Gallup, NM 87301
All contents property of the
Gallup Independent.
Any duplication or republication requires consent of the
Gallup
Independent.
Feel free to send any questions or comments to
gallpind@cia-g.com
E-mail the webmaster at
martyr_dom@hotmail.com
for problems concerning the website ONLY.