Navajo panel fights 'double-dipping'
Jim Maniaci
Diné Bureau
WINDOW ROCK The Education Committee will again try to convince
the Navajo Nation Council to prohibit delegates from "double-dipping"
by serving on tribal school boards.
By a 6-0-1 vote, the committee agreed to take the matter to the council
as part of a school board reform package.
The reform resolution will ask for changes in government, education
and election codes.
The proposed education code reforms would also require board members
to report monthly to their chapters and would forbid them from using
tribal or federal money to sue the tribe. It also would allow a board
to remove a member who misses three consecutive regular meetings.
Another big change, aimed at encouraging younger voters to run for
office, would lower the minimum age to 18 years. To fight nepotism,
the changes would forbid the board member or spouse from being an
employee at the same school.
The five-year limitation for felony convictions, however, would be
deleted. A long list of misdemeanor convictions would be added as
well as ethics convictions.
Another provision, also aimed at keeping delegates from double-dipping,
would forbid council members from serving on more than one school
board at a time.
Delegate James Bilagody, backed by Calvin Kirk and Wallace Charley
compromised on some of the issues so the rest of the package passed.
Delegates Emerson Jackson and Christine Apache, however, scolded the
trio for not standing up for what the people want as expressed in
public hearings that council members should not be double-dipping
as school board members.
Bilagody said he would rather have three-fourths of the cake than
none at all and that "We shouldn't throw the baby out with the
bathwater."
Education Division Director Genevieve Jackson was asked for comments
by the council. Delegates wanted to be on school boards, she said,
when their council salary was $25,000 a year including meeting stipends
and mileage. With the salary increase to $35,000 a year, she said,that
appears to have changed,.
"That makes a big difference and the council will be more prone
to look at it this way," Jackson said.
Another method for satisfying the public, she said, would be to require
school board members to be parents. "That would eliminate more
than half the council delegates."
The committee did accept an amendment to grant an exemption to the
conflict of interest law. In previous attempts, so many delegates
were involved in conflict, no quorum could be formed to act on the
measure.
In the forthcoming session, there are 14 fewer delegates, 22, who
also hold elected positions on tribal school boards.
The reform would allow delegates to hold county-elected offices, however.
Three delegates presently hold offices as commissioners: Charley (San
Juan County), Mark Maryboy (San Juan County, Utah) and Bennie Shelly
(McKinley County).
But the change would also forbid a delegate from serving as an elected
official of a political subdivision of a state. For example, Descheny
serves on the Gallup-McKinley County School Board.
| Top |
Begaye: Prejudice still exists
Navajos note King's battle for civil rights
Larry Di Giovanni
Staff Writer
WINDOW ROCK Navajo President Kelsey Begaye, speaking to a small
but attentive crowd on the Martin Luther King Jr. holiday, made a
convincing argument that one man's misunderstanding is another man's
racial discrimination.
On Saturday, Begaye and wife Marie decided on a soup and salad sit-down
at Dominic's Downtown Cafe on West Coal in Gallup. Parking was tight,
so Begaye dropped Marie off at a nearby store to retrieve shoes she
had ordered repaired. They were to meet in the restaurant.
Begaye said he was surprised when his spouse met him outside the cafe.
She said the manager asked her to leave the establishment.
"I said, 'What?'" Begaye recalled. "I didn't believe
her."
Marie Begaye, minus her jacket and apparently holding an open box
with her shoes inside, was a Native American who appeared to be attempting
to sell her ware at Dominic's. Such actions are not permitted by many
establishments in Gallup.
"Before she could explain, she was actually told to leave the
restaurant," said Begaye, who added that even in this day, open
discrimination against minorities exists.
Dominic's manager, who would identify himself only as "Nick,"
confirmed Saturday's events. He described what occurred as a "misunderstanding."
"It was an oversight on my part," Nick said.
Earlier that day, Nick said he had asked "10 to 15 drunks"
to leave Dominic's, as well as a half-dozen or so Native Americans
selling jewelry. Nick said he had no idea who Marie Begaye was when
he approached her.
"She (Marie) says, 'I'm not selling; I'm just waiting,'"
Nick said. "So I said, 'Well, can you just wait outside?'
"It wasn't in a mean way."
Restaurant managers become conditioned over a day's time to sending
out the riffraff, Nick said.
"Everybody says the same thing: 'I'm not selling,'" Nick
said. "But sooner or later, they are."
Even in border towns with tolerant reputations, such as Gallup, Navajos
and other Native Americans should not assume they will receive the
type of civil rights that King died for, Begaye said. This would include
the right to equal protection under the law in a public place.
"If it can happen to the first lady of the Navajo Nation, it
can happen to everybody," Begaye said.
Begaye said he and his wife made a point to go back into Dominic's
and dine.
Asked if his mistaken assumption of peddling resulted in a complimentary
or reduced-price meal for the Begayes, Nick responded it certainly
did not.
"If he (Begaye) wants to crucify somebody for making a mistake,
that's fine," Nick said.
Perhaps more attuned to the spirit of the Martin Luther King Jr. holiday
was Ni'Asia McIntosh, 2, propelled in a stroller by her mom as the
tot carried a sign, "Civil Rights Movement Helped All Minorities."
Ni'Asia and her mom, Elisa Tsosie of Fort Defiance, were part of a
group that walked from the Window Rock Fairgrounds to Veterans Memorial
Park with a police escort.
"It (the holiday) means a lot to me because my daughter is half
black and half Navajo," Tsosie said, adding that if King were
alive, he would be helping biracial children establish their identities.
The Window Rock organizer for the Martin Luther King Jr. holiday was
Sonlatsa Jim-James, creator of the grass-roots Indigenous Freedom
and Social Justice movement. She is also of mixed heritage, being
half Navajo and half Modoc.
Navajos discriminating against other Navajos on the Navajo Nation
is a problem, but never an excuse for even worse behavior, she said.
"If you allow violence into your own home, your own language,
you are not living the dream (of King)," Jim-James said.
Navajo Nation lead prosecutor Donovan Brown, who is half Caucasian
and half Caddo, was one of four people honored by Jim-James with a
"Freedom Award" from the Indigenous Freedom and Social Justice
Movement. He received his for organizing a conference that brought
tribal awareness to the escalating problem of domestic violence.
Brown said his dad died when he was a year old, which resulted in
his mom, who is Caucasian, surviving abusive relationships to raise
him in eastern Oklahoma.
"So on behalf of her, I accept this award," Brown said.
| Top |
Grants OKs $8 million pact with OMI
Tara Drolma
Staff Writer
GRANTS The Grants City Council has voted to spend $8 million
over the next eight years on a new contract with OMI, the private
company that has been managing the city's water, waste water, landscape
and landscape maintenance services.
All of the discussion was held in executive session. Voters who attended
the session Friday knew no more about the contract that was agreed
upon when they left two hours later than when they had arrived.
Rueben Aranda, who works for OMI, was not present.
When the council convened at 3:30 p.m., Mayor Bill Snodgrass read
item one of the agenda stating they would go into closed session pursuant
to Section 10-15-1(H)(6), NMSA. This clause in the Open Meetings Act
allows government bodies to go into closed session to discuss purchases
exceeding $2,500 that can be made only from one source and to discuss
the contents of competitive sealed proposals that have been solicited
and are being discussed during the contract negotiation process.
According to the meeting's agenda the city had made a Request for
Proposals for two contracts and OMI had submitted proposals. The closed
session was to negotiate the terms of the agreements for the two contracts.
It is not unusual for the city to have only one bidder on sales and
contracts and that was apparently the case with the two RFPs the city
advertised for these contracts.
The contracts were for "Water and Wastewater Operation, Maintenance,
and Management Services" and "Landscape and Maintenance
Services."
Three OMI representatives met with the council in closed session.
The council reconvened at 5:25 p.m. and the mayor reread item number
one to emphasize the reason for the closed session.
Next, the mayor called for a motion on the first contract, the one
for water and wastewater operations. Robert Ulibarri moved to approve
the motion. In his motion he stated the cost for the contract would
be $713,714 and he referred to it as"cost option two." The
motion was seconded, and passed unanimously. Shirley Taylor explained
she voted yes because several of the concerns that had been expressed
by her constituents were clarified.
The mayor called for a motion on item No. 2, the contract for landscape
services. Bob Ortiz motioned to approve option No. 4 for $298,479.
Ortiz and Ulibarri voted yes, Taylor voted nay.
Taylor said she was concerned that there was a conflict of interest
between a councilman and the company and she was concerned about the
length of the eight-year contract. This was the first and only mention
of the length of the contract. The mayor voted yes and broke the tie.
The meeting was adjourned and the council left the chambers.
The only time the mayor, Ortiz, and Ulibarri spoke was when they read
from prepared statements. Even the normally verbal Taylor kept her
remarks to a few short sentences.
During a telephone interview Monday, Taylor clarified some of the
details. Both of the contracts are eight-year contracts. The city
will pay OMI a total of just over $1 million each year.
Taylor said both contracts include other, non-monetary benefits that
are significant. She said the city will pay all costs for the waste
water operating plant except for the chemicals that are used.
Taylor said, "We (taxpayers) pay for OMI's vehicles." According
to Taylor the city also furnishes office space and pays the maintenance
on OMI vehicles.
Taylor added, "We did not negotiate anything. We simply listened
to a presentation by OMI and asked questions. And, as usual, I was
the only one who had questions this thing was cut and dried before
we went in there."
No one, including Taylor, seemed to know why the meeting was called
for 3:30 p.m. Friday. Agendas for the special meeting were not available
until after 4 p.m. the day before.
| Top |
Athletes of the week
Michael Peretti
Staff Sports Writer
The Athletes of the Week for the week of Jan. 8-14 are Zuni Thunderbird
Shawn Simplicio and Monument Valley Lady Mustang Lorena Sullivan.
Simplicio, a senior at Zuni High School, helped his team to a 7-5
record and helped them win the Lordsburg Invitational this weekend
in Lordsburg.
In the first round Simplicio scored 22 points as Zuni defeated Academia
Juarez, 87-74. In the second round he scored 12 to help the Thunderbirds
past Animas, 69-59. In the championship game Simplicio scored 22 again
as Zuni beat Pine Hill 81-62.
Simplicio was selected to the All Tourney team.
"I am surprised," said Simplicio of being selected as the
Athlete of the Week. "There are so many good athletes around
here and on my team, I didn't think I would be picked."
"He has played really well," said Zuni head coach Bob Kercher.
"He's a team player. He is the team's quarterback."
Kercher said Simplicio is a team leader on and off the court. "I
can't say enough about him. He's a very good kid and just has fun
playing the game."
Simplicio said he thinks he has done pretty good so far this season.
"I have to give a lot of credit to the rest of my team and my
coaches. They have helped me and taught me not to be afraid to take
charge and do what I have to do to help the team."
Simplicio said he and the Thunderbirds struggled at the beginning
of the season, but he thinks they are prepared for district. "In
district we have no size, but we have a lot of speed. If we keep on
doing what we have been doing lately, and keep winning on the road
I think we will do pretty good. There are a lot of competitive teams
in our district."
When he graduates, Simplicio said he plans to go to college and plans
to study to become a physical therapist, a coach or a physical education
teacher.
As well as basketball, he also competes in track and was a member
of the Zuni football team this year.
Sullivan, a senior at Monument Valley High School in Keyenta, was
selected as Athlete of the week for the second time this season. Sullivan
was the Athlete of the Week on Nov. 28.
"It feels great again," she said of being selected for the
second time. "It feels good to be on the cover of the sports
again."
Sullivan said that since the last time she was selected, she has had
some problems on the court, but thinks that she has worked things
out. "I kind of had some problems the past two games, but came
over that and just relaxed, and now I am playing better."
Sullivan scored 26 points this weekend when the Lady Mustangs defeated
Window Rock 67-51 to improve to 13-3, 2-3 in conference. Fifteen of
the 26 points came in the first quarter for her.
"The last few games have been pretty tough," she said. "But
hopefully we will do better during regionals in the next two to three
weeks. I will definitely play tougher with my team and hope we can
do well."
Monument Valley coach Robert Nash said Sullivan is a consistent player
and has been for the past three years.
"She is a good shooter, that is her main strength, and she is
one of our three captains."
Nash added that Sullivan averages 16-18 points a game, but could have
more, but she gets taken out if the team has a big lead.
"She does not have a strong quarter, she is pretty consistent
the entire game. That is the strength of our ball club, they all are
pretty consistent," he said.
Ramah girls 7th at Cliff; Grants loses
Prep basketball
Staff report
The Ramah girls captured seventh place at the Cliff Invitational with
a 70-62 win over Reserve.
Ramah outscored Reserve 27-10 in the third period to key the win.
Marlenna Ghahate tallied 18 points with Dana Pino with 15 for the
Lady Mustangs.
Reserve's leading scorers were Vivica Dusablon with 21, Priscilla
Lucero 12 and K. Laney 10.
Espanola 39, Grants 30
Injuries and foul trouble plagued Grants as the Lady Pirates fell
to visiting Espanola 39-30.
Berna Frigerio had a slight concussion at the start of the fourth
period and left the game. Tiffany Hobbs had a hip pointer and Jenna
Lucero fouled out.
"We had a chance to win but we lost several players," Grants
coach Al Torske said.
Jenna Lucero and Juana Torivio each tallied 10 points for Grants.
Grants downed Cobre 40-25 Friday night at home in its district opener.
Torivio and Antonia Dominguez each tallied 10 points for Grants.
"We didn't play very good but we shot the ball well," Torske
said.
Grants, 3-13 overall, 1-0 in district, will play at Crownpoint Tuesday
before traveling to Socorro Friday for a district game.
Boys Crownpint 80, Navajo Pine 67
The Crownpoint Eagles pulled away in the second quarter to beat visiting
Navajo Pine 80-67.
"I am pleased overall. They had a slow started but they came
back at the end," said Crownpoint coach Rick Pawela.
The Eagles scored 31 points in the second quarter, helped them put
the game away.
Leading the Eagles in scoring was Collin Henio with 23 points and
16 rebounds. Michael Norton finished with 20 points and Marques Johnson
walked away with 13 points and 14 rebounds.
Leading Navajo Pine was Carilus Stevens with 22 points.
Crownpoint finished 9-for-19 at the line with 55 rebounds and Navajo
Pine was 15-for-15 at the line.
Crownpoint will play Shiprock at home on Saturday.
| Top |
Greenhouse in Grants purchased
Tara Drolma
Staff Writer
GRANTS The leasehold interest with the City of Grants, buildings
and equipment belonging to the ailing Colorado Greenhouse Company
were sold at a foreclosure sale Wednesday at the Cibola County Courthouse.
Colorado Greenhouse had entered into a lease with the city of Grants
for $1 a year as part of an agreement for the company to bring its
business to town and provide much needed employment. The terms of
the lease included use of the water rights for the production of hydroponically
grown tomatoes.
The company built several very large greenhouses on the property located
adjacent to the golf course before going bankrupt last January. It
was this lease and the buildings that were sold last Wednesday.
The purchaser was Production Credit Association, attorney Bruce Boynton
said...
| Top |
New lawmakers to grapple with old issues
Walter Howerton Jr.
Managing Editor
SANTA FE Voters in the Gallup area sent two fresh faces to
the New Mexico Legislature this year. But when Patty Lundstrom and
Lidio Rainaldi take their seats today, they will be facing some of
the same old issues.
Because New Mexico has the same old governor, Gary Johnson, and he
has the same old agenda. And less than two years to get anything done
about it.
Lundstrom took the seat formerly held by Dave Pederson in the House.
Pederson surrendered the seat to run for the state Senate seat of
the retiring Sen. Gloria Howes. Rainaldi then defeated Pederson...
| Top |
King's dream of racial unity still alive
Tanya Brazil
Staff Writer
GALLUP Gallup residents celebrated racial unity and peace
with music, dance and inspirational speeches Tuesday during the
Martin Luther King Jr. Day festivities at the Gallup Recreation
Center.
Mona Frazier, the newly elected president of the National Association
for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP)-Gallup Chapter, said
this was the first year city employees had the day off and were
able to participate in the march to commemorate the peace movement
led by King.
The peace march was a success, she said, with about 400 people participating
and the numbers growing every year.
The keynote speaker, the Rev. Ruth Gilbert of the Howard Chapel-African
Methodist Episcopal (AME) church, recounted the civil rights leader's
lifetime of accomplishments prior to his assassination in 1968...
| Top
|
Head Start gets back in shape
Jim Maniaci
Diné Bureau
WINDOW ROCK The Navajo Nation's $27.8 million Head Start program,
traditionally in trouble with the federal government for failure to
meet standards, expects to be taken off the non-compliance list, the
Education Committee learned Friday.
In a progress report accepted by the council's oversight committee,
Department Director Kaibah Begay reviewed improvements made the past
year to the 4,000-plus children's program for ages 3-5. They fill
155 classes at 115 centers on the Navajo Nation.
While $6.5 million is in reverted status for not being used, Begay
said this was during a three-year period and a special financial bureau
is being set up to keep track of the income so it can be spent within
the first three quarters. In fiscal year 1997 the total was $1.2 million;
in 1998, $3.2 million, and in 1999, $2 million...
| Top
|
Teachers' union gives support to Esquibel, Bright
Bill Donovan
Staff Writer
GALLUP The local teachers' union would like to see Marty
Esquibel and Bill Bright elected to the school board.
Tom Payton, president of the McKinley County Federation of United
School Employees, said the union believes that Esquibel, who is
running in District 5, and Bright, in District 4, would benefit
both teachers and students if elected.
The union also supports Johnny R. Thompson, but because he is running
unopposed in District 2, Payton said that the union
plans to make no formal endorsement.
The election will be held countywide on Feb. 6...
Deaths
Ross Lee Francis
GAMERCO Services for Ross Francis, 73, will be held at 7 p.m.
today, Jan. 16, at the Joshua Generation for Jesus, 1375 Elva Dr.
Cal Jones will officiate.
Francis died Jan. 11 in Gallup. He was born Feb. 5, 1927, in Versailles,
Mo.
His hobbies included outdoor sports, fishing and hunting.
Survivors include his wife, Jean L. Francis of Gamerco; son, Tim L.
Francis of Gamerco; daughters, Shirley Feldhusen of Scottsdale, Ariz.,
Edith Hazel of Carencro, La., and Karen Francis of Phoenix; brother,
Jack T. Francis of Phoenix; and six
grandchildren.
Francis was preceded in death by parents, John and Nettie Francis;
sister, Marilyn Wood; and brother, Edward Francis.
Cope Memorial Chapel is in charge of arrangements.
Lorraine Jumbo Sells
ROUGH ROCK, Ariz. Graveside services for Lorraine Jumbo Sells,
73, will be held at 10 a.m. Wednesday, Jan. 17, on family land inRough
Rock. Melvin Harold will officiate.
Sells died Jan. 13 in Chinle, Ariz. She was born Dec. 12, 1927, in
Many Farms, Ariz. into the Tl'ogi (Zia) for the Red Running into the
Water People Clan.
Survivors include her sons, Earl Sells of Teec Nos Pos, Ariz., Bennie
Sells, Larry Sells, Lawerence Sells and Terry Sells, all of Rough
Rock; daughters, Lorina Grey and Michelle Pinto, both of Rough Rock;
sisters, Evelyn Tso of Chinle, Ariz., Alice Segina of Many Farms,
and Grace Gray of Kayenta, Ariz.; 31 grandchildren and 24 great-grandchildren.
Sells was preceded in death by her husband, Kit Sells; son, Gilbert
Sells; brothers, David Jumbo, Richard Jumbo, Eddie
Jumbo, Howard Jumbo; and sister, Elizabeth Etsitty.
Pallbearers will be family and relatives.
The family will receive friends and relatives after the burial services
at the family residence, Rough Rock.
Tse Bonito Mortuary is in charge of arrangements.
Alvin P. Phlieger
GALLUP Services for Alvin P. Phileger, 69, will be held at
10 a.m. Tuesday, Jan. 16, at Sacred Heart Cathedral. Father Pat Universal
will officiate. Burial will follow at St. Michaels Cemetery, Collyer,
Kan.
Phlieger died Jan. 14 in Gallup. He was born Nov. 2, 1931, in Quinter,
Kan.
Phlieger was a member of the Elks Lodge and AIME. He received his
degree from Kansas State University.
Survivors include his wife, Sharon Phlieger of Gallup; son, Michael
D. Phlieger of Albuquerque; daughter, Shawnda M.
Osborn of Belen; brother, Gilbert Phlieger of Garden City, Kan.; sisters,
Renalda Fitzpatrick of Phoenix and Annette Phlieger and Loretta Turner,
both of Quinter, Kan.; and three grandchildren.
Phlieger was preceded in death by parents, Michael and Rosina Phlieger;
brother, Norbert Phlieger; and sister, Armella Marie Phlieger.
Pallbearers will be Aaron Curtis, Scott Curtis, Mark Heppler, Michael
Heppler, James Meisner and Danny Osborn.
Rollie Mortuary is in charge of arrangements.
Freddie L. Anderson
GRANTS Services for Freddie L. Anderson, 79, will be held at
10 a.m. Saturday, Jan. 20, at Mount Calvary Lutheran Church. The Rev.
Armin Stolp will officiate. Burial will follow at Grants Memorial
Park.
Visitation will be at held from 4-7 p.m. Friday, Jan. 19, at Grants
Mortuary Chapel.
Anderson was born Aug. 31, 1921, in Miami, Ariz.
Survivors include her son, John Anderson of Albuquerque; brothers,
Richard Cromer of Oracle, Ariz., Ben Stepp of North Carolina and Roy
Stepp of Phoenix; sister, Dorothy McCoy of Miami, Ariz.; three grandchildren
and four great-grandchildren.
Anderson was preceded in death by her husband, Norma J. Anderson.
Pallbearers will be Larry MacKendrick, Shawn Anderson, Ian Anderson,
Robert Clark, Bill Cromer and Jon Anderson.
Correction
TOHATCHI The obituary published for Rambo Becenti, 53, inadvertently
omitted that he was preceded in death by his father, Frank Norton
Sr. The name was incorrect in Saturday's edition.
Contact the Gallup
Independent
Please send the Gallup Independent feedback on
this website and the paper in general.
E-mail: gallpind@cia-g.com
By mail:
The Independent
PO Box 1210 Gallup, NM 87305
500 N. 9th Gallup, NM 87301
All contents property of the
Gallup Independent.
Any duplication or republication requires consent of the
Gallup
Independent.
Feel free to send any questions or comments to
gallpind@cia-g.com
E-mail the webmaster at
martyr_dom@hotmail.com
for problems concerning the website ONLY.